臺灣博碩士論文加值系統

本研究利用性能式設計法來進行體育場觀眾席人員逃生避難檢討，首先探討案例的建築物內部設計條件，如觀眾席配置、步行距離、出口寬度、觀眾席數等，接著進行案例逃生避難時間分析，探討案例中逃生動線設計、驗證方法種類、人員逃生情形及逃生效率之改善，藉由三種性能設計法針對建築物作為避難設計之先期評估，將模擬結果以圖表及數據量化與原設計模型進行比對分析，並提出建議修正方案，在符合經濟效益且合理的需求下，達到建築物避難安全之最佳化設計。
本研究案例分析架構可分為避難驗證方法之比較、避難設施配置對逃生之影響、逃生效率改善等。案例分析結論可分為以下幾點：
1.對於人員大量集中的建築物，經驗公式為設計階段可快速提供設計者作為初步逃生安全設計的參考依據，但仍需進一步進行電腦動態模擬方能瞭解避難節點位置，進行設計修正。
2.有效的避難分區計畫，可平衡整體避難設施使用率，有助於縮短人員逃生時間，逃生效率約可改善10.71％∼54.5％。
3.觀眾席若欲達到快速疏散之目的，除了走道寬度的配置必須對應此區域觀眾席總席數外，對於樓層內直通樓梯位置、出口位置及避難動線轉折多寡，更是產生避難節點相當關鍵之因素。
4.經驗公式無法呈現建築物內部空間複雜度，計算結果較為理想化，而Simulex軟體可依照建築內部空間進行模擬，仍受於軟體基本假設限制，則視建築物內部空間複雜度情形而有逃生時間拉長的誤差產生，建議應在模擬前進行不合理之逃生路徑修正。

This study analyzes occupant evacuation time in stadium auditoriums by utilizing performance-based design method. Firstly, it discusses the internal safety design conditions of the building, such as auditorium configuration, walking distance, exit width, and auditorium quantity. Then it analyzes occupant evacuation time and explores the design of evacuate moving route, Authentication method, occupant evacuation situation and evacuation efficiency improvement.
This study uses three kinds of performance based design method to evaluate for egress design in advance. To compare the simulation results with original model, based on cost efficiency and reasonable demand, and then provide the best suggestion.
The framework of this study includes comparison of refuge authentication method, the Influences of refuge facility configuration on the escaping and how to improve the fleeing efficiency.
The following conclusions are obtained by this research：
1.When staff concentrate in the building, we can apply equation to evacuation safety designing preliminary and then dynamic programming in egress simulates is necessary that in order to find the evacuation node and avoided.
2.Effective zoning evacuation planning can adjust the facility usage rate and can speed up fleeing time. Per the study, the evacuation efficiency can be improved 10.71%~54.5%.
3.The aisle width need matched auditoriums to accomplich quick evacuation but more importantly , stairs location, exit location and amounts of evacuate routing bend are also be considered as well for avoiding evacuation node.
4.The calculation result is too idealized because equation can’t reply interior space complexities of building. Although Simulex software can applied to evacuation simulation but deviation is still existed due to the limitation of basic assumptions. The suggestion is to revise evacuate moving route before simulation.

摘要.................................................................i
ABSTRACT............................................................ii
誌謝................................................................iv
目錄.................................................................v
表目錄............................................................viii
圖目錄...............................................................x
第一章 緒論..........................................................1
1.1 研究動機與目的...................................................1
1.2 文獻回顧.........................................................4
1.3 研究內容.........................................................6
1.4 研究流程.........................................................8
第二章 體育場空間型態之特性分析......................................9
2.1 體育場空間之特性.................................................9
2.2 使用人員之特性..................................................10
2.3 體育場疏散特徵..................................................11
第三章 國內外相關規範及防火性能式設計...............................12
3.1 我國防災相關法規回顧............................................12
3.2 體育場相關建築法規..............................................13
3.2.1 建築技術規則..................................................13
3.2.2 體育場安全設計指南............................................14
3.2.3 國內外設計規範彙整............................................15
3.3 逃生時間檢討標準................................................17
3.4 防火性能式設計..................................................18
3.4.1 性能式法規之目的..............................................18
3.4.2 性能式防火安全設計............................................18
3.4.3 規格式與性能式法規之優缺點....................................18
第四章 避難模擬軟體與驗證計算方法介紹...............................20
4.1 避難模擬軟體(Simulex)...........................................20
4.1.1 Simulex限制...................................................22
4.1.2 人員尺寸......................................................22
4.1.3 行進速度......................................................24
4.1.4 超越角度......................................................27
4.2 建築物防火避難安全性能驗證技術手冊..............................29
4.2.1 適用範圍及限制................................................29
4.2.2 居室避難安全驗證..............................................30
4.3 英國「體育場安全設計指南」......................................32
4.3.1 人員逃生時間計算方法..........................................32
4.3.2 逃生時間標準..................................................33
第五章 體育場案例分析...............................................34
5.1 體育場案例簡介..................................................34
5.1.1 前言..........................................................34
5.1.2 建築概要......................................................35
5.1.3 觀眾席避難規劃................................................36
5.1.4 平面規劃說明..................................................38
5.2 避難安全驗證參數設定............................................41
5.2.1 驗證方式因應原則..............................................41
5.2.2 內野下層觀眾席避難檢討分析說明................................43
5.2.3 內野中層觀眾席避難檢討分析說明................................44
5.2.4 內野上層觀眾席避難檢討分析說明................................45
5.2.5 外野下層觀眾席避難檢討分析說明................................47
5.2.6 外野中層觀眾席避難檢討分析說明................................48
5.3 避難安全驗證檢討................................................49
5.3.1 內野下層觀眾席................................................49
5.3.2 內野中層觀眾席................................................54
5.3.3 內野上層觀眾席................................................58
5.3.4 外野下層及中層觀眾席..........................................63
5.3.5 綜合比較......................................................66
5.4 逃生設計改善....................................................66
5.4.1 內野下層情境說明..............................................66
5.4.2 內野下層模擬結果..............................................81
5.4.3 內野上層情境說明..............................................81
5.4.4 內野上層模擬結果..............................................99
5.5 模擬結果應用...................................................100
第六章 結論與建議..................................................103
參考文獻...........................................................106
附錄A 觀眾席避難安全驗證時間計算...................................108

1.內政部營建署, “建築技術規則”, 2011
2.內政部消防署, “各類場所消防安全設備設置標準”, 2011
3.內政部建築研究所,“建築物防火避難安全性能驗證技術手冊”,2004
4.Department for Culture, Media and Sport，DCMS,“Guide to Safety at Sports Grounds”,2008 Edition
5.內政部消防署, “大型空間（購物中心、巨蛋等）避難及救災安全管理對策”, 2005
6.江柏助, “建築物避難設計先期評估之研究”, 交通大學產業安全與防災學程碩士論文, 2002
7.張書維, “體育館空間避難路徑之視覺模擬研究”, 中國文化大學建築與都市計劃研究所碩士論文, 2004
8.吳俊毅, “運用EXODUS避難軟體進行避難所需時間”, 中央警察大學消防科學研究所碩士論文, 2000
9.Ethel Graat, Cees Midden and Paul Bockholts, “Complex evacuation; effects of motivation level and slope of stairs on emergency egress time in a sports stadium” , Department of Technology Management, Eindhoven University of Technology,1999
10.黃莉芸, “應用Simulex模擬公共建築避難時間之研究-以大型量販店為例”, 朝陽科技大學建築及都市設計研究所碩士論文, 2010
11.丁育群, “高層建築防火設施規劃設計之研究” ,中國文化大學建築及都市計畫研究所博士論文, 1987
12.林慶元、蕭江碧, “建築技術規則防火安全有關規定之修訂-第四章防火避難設施及消防設備” ,內政部營建署, 2000
13.陳火炎, “建築物消防避難問題之研究” , 中央警官學校警政研究所碩士論文 ,1982
14.藤本盛久、羽倉弘人, “現代建築防災工學” ,オ－ム社 ,1981
15.鄭琮琰, “大型空間展覽場展覽活動之避難安全評估之研究-以台北世貿展覽館為例” ,中原大學室內設計研究所碩士論文 ,2003
16.內政部消防署, “消防法” ,2011
17.內政部消防署, “消防法施行細則” ,2011
18.丁育群、周智中、陳火炎, “建築物性能防火法規之規劃研究” ,內政部建築研究所 ,1997
19.Integrated Environmental Solutions Ltd ,“Simulex User Manual Evacuation modeling software” ,1998
20.Ricketts, G. ,”An investigation into the density and flow of people in public spaces by image analysis”,Hons dissertation., Dept of Civil Engineering and Building Science, University of Edinburgh ,1994
21.British Standards Institute Staff ,“Spectator Facilities. Layout Criteria for Spectator Viewing Area. Specification” ,2004